top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Twitter Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon

This Day in History: Susan B. Anthony Arrested

11 minutes ago
3 min read

On this day in 1872, Susan B. Anthony finds herself in trouble with the law. Mere days earlier, the determined suffragist had walked into a New York polling place and cast a vote.

 

Now federal authorities were coming for her.

 

Anthony’s work for women’s suffrage is well known, of course, but did you know a Quaker upbringing helped shape her lifelong crusade?

 

Quakers were abolitionists, holding firmly to “the equality of all people before God.” Education for both girls and boys was valued, and Anthony herself was well-educated. Yet she also noticed something else in those years: Why didn’t her father ever hire a woman to oversee his cotton factory?

 

The question followed her into adulthood, although she focused on abolitionist causes at first. She criticized Abraham Lincoln’s moderate views and was even burned in effigy once! But the emphasis of her work turned to equality for women.

 

She and other suffragettes testified before Congress, trying (and failing) to obtain protections for women under the 14th or 15th amendments. Finally, in 1872, Anthony tried another approach: She would register to vote.

 

Her local voter registration was held in a barber shop. So, on November 1, she and her sisters boldly walked in. Election inspectors at first resisted the women, but Anthony lobbed one last arrow.

 

“If you refuse us our rights as citizens,” she asserted, “I will bring charges against you in Criminal Court and I will sue each of you personally for large, exemplary damages . . . if I have to, I will push to the ‘last ditch’ in both courts.”

 

The men consulted a supervisor, ultimately deciding that the onus of the affair should be on Anthony. Thus, they caved, and other women were soon registering, too.

 

The inspectors’ troubles were just beginning, though. Four days later, these women arrived at a polling place, determined to vote. Two of three inspectors agreed, although one later said he felt trapped.

 

“Decide which way we might, we were liable to prosecution,” he testified. “We were expected . . . to make an infallible decision . . . of a question in which some of the best minds of the country are divided.”

 

“Well I have been & gone & done it!!” Anthony wrote a friend, noting that others had accomplished the same feat.

 

Perhaps unsurprisingly, her victory proved short-lived. Just two weeks later, Anthony was arrested, although she found a bit of humor in the deputy marshal sent to retrieve her.

 

“He sat down,” she explained. “He said it was pleasant weather. He hemmed and hawed and finally said Mr. Storrs wanted to see me. . . . ‘what for?’ I asked. ‘To arrest you,’ said he. ‘Is that the way you arrest men?’ ‘No.’ Then I demanded that I should be arrested properly.”

 

It turned out that other women—and even the election inspectors!—had been arrested as well.

 

When Anthony’s trial was held months later, the judge didn’t let the jury deliberate. He simply directed a guilty verdict and levied a fine. But then, as a Library of Congress website muses, “[he] mistakenly asked if she had anything to say.”

 

“May it please your honor,” she retorted, “I shall never pay a dollar of your unjust penalty.” She was proud that she’d educated other women to “rebel against your man-made, unjust, unconstitutional forms of law, that tax, fine, imprison and hang women, while they deny them the right of representation . . . .”

 

“Resistance to tyranny,” she quoted, “is obedience to God.”

 

She never did pay that fine. But she didn’t get to see the fruits of her labor, either. Instead, she passed away long before the 19th Amendment was ratified in 1920. Yet she’d never lost her faith in the cause.

 

Mere weeks before her death, she’d declared: “Failure is impossible.”

A note for those who are interested: Some of you might know I am running an experiment in history reels. If you are so inclined, check out my YouTube channel and/or subscribe to those HERE. Don’t miss the reel I created about the 12-year-old who served in World War II, posted over the weekend. 
Available on Amazon, barnesandnoble.com, or TaraRoss.com/books
Available on Amazon, barnesandnoble.com, or TaraRoss.com/books

Primary Sources:

Comments


For media inquiries,

please contact Colonial Press

info at colonialpressonline dot com

Dallas, TX

Sign up for news and updates

from Tara Ross

Thanks for loving history with me!

© Copyright 2026 by Tara Ross.

bottom of page